Sunday, November 8, 2009

Sarah Palin Compares Elderly Care In Healthcare Bill To Abortion


More details of Sarah Palin's speech to the Wisconsin Right To Life group are coming out - including these excerpts from Jonathan Martin of Politico:

Sarah Palin rallied thousands of abortion opponents Friday night with a a stark warning that the same philosophy that allows abortion rights could soon be invoked to allow the government to cut off health care for the elderly or children with special needs.

Speaking to a fund-raising banquet of Wisconsin Right to Life, the former Alaska governor and 2008 Republican vice presidential nominee asserted that if policy-makers don’t believe a child in the womb is valuable, then “perhaps the same mind-set applies to other persons.”

“What may they feel about an elderly person who doesn’t have a whole lot of productive years left,” Palin asked an audience of about 5,000 who paid $30 each to hear her speak in an airplane hangar-like exhibition hall at the Wisconsin state fairgrounds just outside of Milwaukee. “In order to save government money, government health care has to be rationed… [so] than this elderly person that perhaps could be seen as costing taxpayers to pay for a non-productive life? Do you think our elderly will be first in line for limited health care?

“And what about the child who perhaps isn’t deemed normal or perfect per someone’s subjective measure of their use or questionable purpose in the eyes of a panel of bureaucrats making our health care decisions for us,” she continued.

Her warning was couched in repeated rhetorical questions about what might happen when laws are made by those she portrayed as having an insufficient appreciation for the sanctity of all human life.

“We have to think this through,” she said. “We have to get to the truth of this matter, health care reform.”

The fund-raiser was advertised as closed to media coverage, but at least three reporters, including one from POLITICO, attended simply by purchasing a ticket like other members of the public.

The line to get into the venue here stretched over a half-mile outside the building and a local conservative talk radio station even marked the event by printing t-shirts that welcomed her to the city, noted the date of her appearance and deemed her: “America’s Conservative Conscience.” The anti-abortion group that hosted the event sought to raise money by including pledge cards on every chair that included an offer to become part of “Sarah’s Rogues” by giving $1,000 to the group in exchange for an autographed copy of her forthcoming memoir, “Going Rogue: An American Life.

Palin had remarks prepared but frequently wandered off-script to make a point, offering audience members a casual “awesome” or “bogus” in discussing otherwise weighty topics.

As in: “It is so bogus that society is sending a message right now and has been for probably the last 40 years that a woman isn’t strong enough or smart enough to be able to pursue an education, a career and her rights and still let her baby live.”

Palin also offered flashes of the traits that endear her to many conservatives. Offering great personal detail, she relayed the story of how she came to find out that her infant son, Trigg, had Down Syndrome. She confessed to being scared and said that she and her husband, Todd, turned to God to prepare them.

After years of advocating against abortion in theory – what she called “preaching to the choir” – Palin said she was presented with the stark reality of what to do with a special-needs baby.

“I am thankful to have been asked to walk the walk,” she said.

Palin also included a few less personal, but as compelling, flourishes in her remarks, citing Pope John Paul II (never a bad idea in a heavily-Catholic part of the country), referring to scripture (John 16:13) and noting that such feminist pioneers as Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton had opposed abortion (she called them “foremothers”).

She also demonstrated a politician’s ability to connect with a local crowd, relating that her grandmother was born in Chippewa Falls, her dad had played high school football with Packers great Jerry Kramer and, with an audience that likely watched a lot of Fox News, noted her relationship with the network’s talk show, Wisconsin native Greta Van Susteren.

Further, Palin talked with ease about the abortion issue, touting polling this year that showed a majority of the country opposing the procedure, recalling successful ad campaigns (“Choose Life”) on the issue and casting her own opposition to it in terms familiar to the movement.

Palin didn’t mention President Obama by name, but did take a shot at him for opposing an abortion-related measure as an Illinois state senator and more than once mocked his catch phrase.

"Let's talk about change we can believe in," Palin said. "Friends, a majority of Americans identify as pro life, and thank God for that."

She reserved her toughest critique for House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, eliciting boos from the crowd at the mention of the speaker’s name. Palin urged Pelosi to allow House members to vote on an amendment that would bar any taxpayer funds from being used to fund abortion.

“We need to make sure she hears the message that she will held accountable if she does not let this at least come to a vote of her colleagues so they can have their voice be heard,” Palin said.

In a closing exhortation, she urged the audience, “Don't ever let anyone to tell you to sit down and shut up.”

After she concluded her remarks – and presented the organization with an over-sized, $1,000 check – Palin signed autographs for some of the few hundred people who surged toward the dais.

Alissa Maerzke, 12 and wearing a “Palin 2012” t-shirt, was elated that she got the former governor’s signature.

After collecting a congratulatory hug from her mom, Maerzke recounted that she asked Palin if she was going to run for president. “She just smiled,” said the girl.

In the line on the way into the event, a gentleman wearing a Harley-Davidson fleece pull-over and jeans joked to his friends that he was going to ask Palin to marry him, summing up his devotion this way: “She thinks like I do, she’s absolutely gorgeous and Democrats are afraid of her – what’s not to like?”

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

To Ms. Palin and the other morons spreading her tall tales:

Health care is rationed in America. It is rationed by ability to pay. Currently, seniors get a very disproportionate share of the health care resources, much of the $$ going to keep them alive during the last weeks and months. Often, the efforts are extraordinary.

Unless the Republicans are willing to spend the $$ to give everyone all the health care they want, decisions need to made.

A friend's dad recently went into the hospital at age 94. He couldn't walk or see. His hearing was bad. He didn't want to live. Yet, the hospital kept him alive for six weeks. God knows how many tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands that cost. Kaching Kaching. Meanwhile, many people can't get simple health care for their kids.

Do we want to distribute resources more fairly? Or are the Repubs willing to give up their tax cuts for the rich and non-stop spending on the military to fund health care for all? I think we all know the answer. So shut your mouth, Sarah.

Marcia Brady

Anonymous said...

Sarah Palin, the insurance company lap dog, continues to spread her lies. At least there is one Republican with the guts to stand up to the insurance companies. His name is Joe Cao.

Anonymous said...

Aren't you embarrassed to be supporting Sarah Palin?

Anonymous said...

Marcia Brady:

Right on. We didn't hear the GOP complain about the billions in tax revenues lost when they repealed the Gazillionaire Tax--the tax they cleverly misnamed the DEATH Tax to make Joe Sixpack think the tax had anything to do with him. They didn't complain about the cost of letting the Fortune 500 Companies escape paying ANY corporate income tax by opening an offshore office. Tax cuts for the rich are always affordable to them. They also love the War Machine--although, Marcia, in fairness, so do many Dems.

Bill

Greg said...

It's always fun to see the person posting as Anonymous carrying on a conversation with him or herself.

Anonymous said...

Aren't you embarrassed to be supporting Sarah Palin?



Some people are never embarrassed.

Michael April said...

Nicely put Greg and then IT changes names from Rush to Marcia to whatever to add to their annonyance, all the while complaining they can't 'log in' somethings wrong with the site.

Anonymous said...

Actually, I am not embarrassed at all. If you would have done some actual research in what she accomplished in Alaska, neither would you. Of course, if your information just comes from the lies spewed by people who just want to destroy her, then that is a different story.

It is intriguing that before she was tapped as VP candidate she had an over 80% approval rating in her state, no ethics charges were filed against her (there was one wackjob woman that had it in for her, but that was because she did not get the job she wanted), but then as soon as McCain picked her ethics charges were the norm. No matter that all were found to be without merit. Another fact is that some Alaskan bloggers set up a meeting to get together to try to destroy her. Yet, these same people want to make money at her expense. She is a victim of a dirty tricks campaign that would have made even Richard Nixon jealous.

Never in the history of this country has a VP candidate of a losing election has had so much vitriol sent their way. Then you wonder why people think that she is a considered a threat to liberals? If she was really so inconsequential you all would not bother to write lies and innuendoes on blogs, you would just ignore her.

So, no, I am definitely not embarrassed to support her.

JJ

Anonymous said...

Unfortunately, thanks to her supporters, Sarah Palin has become a caricature. She's a human being who can and does make mistakes. We don't hate her. What YOU have made her into is an object of ridicule.

Elle Leet

Anonymous said...

Elle Leet

"What YOU have made her into is an object of ridicule."

Excuse me, but we are not the ones attributing to her what Tina Fey said: "I can see Russia from my house". Not only is that a false statement but it is continuously repeated as a correct quote and repeated ad nauseum until others believe it as fact.

We are not the ones trying to make money by writing parodies about her and copying the cover of her book in a book full of bloggers' comments and with no substance. We are not the ones with blogs dedicated to innuendoes and false statements regarding the birth of her last child. We are not the ones who in the Comments section of the aforementioned blogs write that "we hate her, we want to see her dead, , make fun or shoes, we would not be happy until she is in jail, etc." (this last one boggles the mind, since even the FBI, who has never done such a thing, had to come out and say that there was no investigation). So, sorry, no, her supporters have NOT done that. That is laid at the feet of the ignorant bloggers that want to destroy her. The same bloggers who get all upset when she has no press at her events then say that she is all over the place wanting publicity.

I guess we will wait and see how her book tour does and how many people show up to see her and get their books signed.

JJ

Anonymous said...

Yes, book signing tours are the ultimate measure of ones ability to lead the county.

No Sarah did not not say she could see Russia from her house, but when she was questioned about her foreign policy experience she did point out that you could see Russia from an island that is part of Alaska and that Alaska shares a border with Canada. We all heard her. Makes you want to cringe. Everything else you describe goes with being a celebrity. I have actually never heard or read anyone wishing she was dead. If you would quit making her into a god, she wouldn't be such an easy target.

Anonymous said...

She is a victim of a dirty tricks campaign that would have made even Richard Nixon jealous.


JJ/Micahel April,

Yes, Sarah is the ultimate victim. Just ask her.

Anonymous said...

Hey Palin supporters, If you want to be celebrity you can't have a thin skin. Oh boo hoo, they made fun of me on SNL, they didn't like my shoes. It all comes with the price of fame. Next time you talk to Sarah, tell her she should have given up politics and become a special needs advocate. She could really made a difference and would have my respect.

Elle Leet

Nalca said...

GOOD GOD, is she really this stupid?